I am posting these as a blog prompt, but they are all suggested topics for you research paper. You may choose to answer any of them in the blog as a way of beginning to think about your papers. Please post AT LEAST 4-5 paragraphs.
1. What is the relationship between memory and forgeting in Duras’ The Lover? What role does photography play in the remembrance of the past? What is the significance of the various images—both photographic ones and ones indelibly etched in the mind?
Consider the following quotation by Carol Hoffman from Forgetting and Marguerite Duras (University of Colorado Press, 1991):
"The repetition of situations, events, memories, and words abounds in Duras’s texts. This repetition seems to emphasize the changing, unstable aspect of memory and language and move the reader to question his or her own memory and examine the dynamics of forgetting. . . . memory is seen as volatile and impossible. It is a movement toward the ever-elusive and often painful ‘impossible,’ the ‘vide’ [‘void’/‘emptiness’], the ‘manque’ [‘lack’], what Jacques Lacan called ‘le réel’ [the real]. It is a remembering that destroys memory and leads to a new memory, which can replace the last only fleetingly and without substance . . . a refusal of convention or disguise, as a unity of thought and will, life and appearance" (35-6).
2. How does Duras incorporate the body into her writing? Is the body the ‘site’ of the written text? or is it the ‘space’ or ‘site’ from which the text arises?
Consider the following quotation by Leslie Hill in Marguerite Duras: Apocalyptic Desires (London & New York: Routledge, 1993):
"For Duras as for Barthes, the body is not a mode of self-identity: the body is a figure of madness, not self-possession. It is not an essence or nature, but a reverse of an essence or nature; it is a name for that which provokes crisis in the realm of representation by producing irreducible difference. And what it denotes most of all, in Duras as in Barthes, is desire" (30).
3. Marguerite Duras's The Lover is narrated from the points of view of age and youth. Although the "older" voice gives perspective and shapes the representation of the youthful self, this is not simply a dialogue or contrast between youth and age. They are intertwined in ways that suggest equally that as the artist recreates the teenage speaker, the latter has given birth to the voice of the artist. The novel chronicles loss (of family, innocence, a great love), mourning, and discovery. The speaker’s re-creation of what she has lost, with frequent references to death, suggest a process of remembering and mourning in her writing. Psychoanalyst Henry Krystal describes adolescence as a transition into adulthood and a time when an individual develops the ability to grieve (63). In this portrait of her development as an adolescent, Duras chronicles her growing capacity to grieve as she tells of individuating herself from her anguished family. Her increased independence coincides with discovering she wants to be a writer, a vocation which provides her the means to frequently revisit this period of trauma and loss the in the book (1) While The Lover tracks a time of transition and a time of loss, it is also during this time that the speaker develops her creative imagination, her ability to relate to others outside of her family, and experiences alienation and sexuality, which all help her transition towards an adult identity. In your essay, explore the ways in which the process of growth and mourning are inextricably bound together and mutually generating in her text.
4. One major theme in the novel is that of transgression - of going beyond or overstepping some boundary. The speaker transgresses, in the sense of "going over" or "going across," when she crosses the Mekong. She transgresses, in the sense of "violating some moral law," by commencing and continuing her affair with her Chinese lover. The family transgresses societal expectations just by virtue of their poverty, and then because of that poverty, by silently condoning the speaker's relationship with her lover. The family transgresses familiar/family ideals: they are not the archetypal loving and supportive family. The style of the novel transgresses traditional temporal/chronological plot structures - i.e. the narrative weaves between the past and the present, using the present tense and past tense to describe the same moments in time. Pastness is collapsed into present, but at the same time, without the past being the past, the speaker would have no subject on which to reflect. What do you think is the importance of transgression? How, as a theme, does it characterize the novel's subject, its style, and its purpose?
Some Useful Places to Look:
1. Marguerite Duras: Apocaliypic Desire, by Leslie Hill
http://books.google.com/books?id=9UYOAAAAQAAJ&dq=Marguerite+Duras+Lover+essay+questions&printsec=frontcover&source=in&hl=en&ei=FF3aSeO6KaTNlQe4tOXFDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=12#PPP1,M1
2. Marguerite Duras, by Renate Gunther
http://books.google.com/books?id=_MZhsT4W7KcC&dq=Marguerite+Duras+Lover+essay+questions&printsec=frontcover&source=in&hl=en&ei=cGTaScv9I9vtlQfro_HCDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=11#PPP1,M1
3. "Image" and Absence in Marguerite Duras' "L'Amant"
by Nina S. Hellerstein
Modern Language Studies, Vol. 21, No. 2 (Spring, 1991), pp. 45-56, Published by: Modern Language Studies (You can find it on JSTOR)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The young French girl is constructed to be very sexual and transgressive. Her love affair with a much older Chinese man is the most transgressive theme in the novel. She knows that she has broken a moral law, thereby convincing herself and the Chinese man that she is not in love with him. She has broken another “moral law” by losing her innocence, her virginity, before marriage. She is told by her mother that she is now ruined and will never marry. I think that she sort of becomes the Chinese man’s prostitute. He proclaims that he is deeply in love with her but she repreatedly states that she does not love him. A major portion of their relationship is sexual and she asks him for money which he gives. They both are aware that they have no future together but cannot discontinue their relationship. She literally has to move away to France to get away from him.
ReplyDeleteThe speaker’s family is also very transgressed. They are very poor. The mother is overly sensitive to the older brother and enables him to gamble away everything by supporting him each time he does something wrong. She supports him financially and pays off his debts. The speaker, who is the youngest of three, refers to her older, middle, brother as her younger brother. She feels that she needs to protect him. She is like a mother figure to him. The mother beats her daughter, the speaker, for having an affair with the Chinese man but also allows it to continue because he is wealthy and gives her money. The family is not a normal family. They are not very loving towards one another and there are hints of incestual relationships between the mother and the older brother and between the speaker and her two brothers.
The style of the novel is also trangressed. Usually novels are linear and chronological. However, this novel jumps back in forth between past and present. There is no order in the book, everything seems to be random. This style tries to replicate the way our memory works. Our memory is not linear, it doesn’t remember things in a linear fashion. It is not a photograph which is just a moment frozen in time. It is the emotions and feelings that are associated with an instance and the impact that the event has on our heart and mind. Memories that are painful as well as joyful.
One of the most dominant themes throughout "The Lover" is transgression. Transgression is moving beyond a boundary, or overstepping a line. Just about every character in this novel commits some act of transgression along the way. The most obvious transgressions come from the main character.
ReplyDeleteThe french girl commits transgressions early and often. At the beginning of the novel she speaks of crossing the "mekong river". Crossing this river is a metaphor for committing transgressions. She was only 15 and a half when she crossed this river. Transgression plays a deeply important role throughout this book because it helps define, and shape the characters. We see through their transgressions who they truly are, and what they truly need.
Transgression helps to define the story, and the style it is written. The story goes back and forth in time, never following a true linear fashion. When the french girl is speaking about her life, she could be speaking in the present or the past. Her memories are blurred. Memories get replaced with other memories, so we are constantly forgetting and pushing out older memories for new ones.
In The Lover by Marguerite Duras, the speaker has a very difficult childhood. She does not like her older brother, because she thought that he was mean. She hated how her mother wanted to control her and how she forced her to study mathematics. She wanted to write books and novels, but the mother disagreed. Due to her miserable relation with her family and her poverty, she transgressed the social norms at the time and began sleeping with the Chinese man for money. Because of that poverty, her family did not disapprove of her relationship with her lover. At the beginning, she only loved him because he was rich. After that, she actually came to love him regardless of his money. She was very scared from her mother because losing virginity at this time was scandal. When her mother knew everything, it was a shock for her and she wanted to kick her out of the house.
ReplyDeleteThe book isn’t about the shocking nature of the relationship. It’s not meant to titillate, and I’ve read books far more explicit. It’s about the knowledge that comes when we cross barriers — some that can only be crossed once, and some that are crossed over and over, like the ferry crossing the Mekong Delta. It’s about learning that those we love are not immortal: “Immortality is mortal,” says Duras, and she means both that it can die and that it can kill. The girl in the novel struggles with her claustrophobic family relationship as much as she does with the painfully intense jouissance that her lover brings her. And in the end, she finds her own way through all of it.
ReplyDeleteThe lover contains elements of Marguerite Duras's autobiography. Marguerite talks about her own growing experience through the speaker. The speaker finds the way out of her impoverished and unhappy family through her lover, the wealthy Chinese older man. The relationship between the speaker and her lover is sexual desire and the care she got from the lover. She does not lover the Chinese man but she needs money. The Chinese man loves her but he has to follow his father's arrangement and marry a Chinese lady. There will be no result between her and her lover. The speaker realized this and took advantage of the passage to have a new life that her mother could never provide her.
ReplyDeleteWen
Best essay writing service yahoo answers I admire this article for the well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so involved in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thank you so much.
ReplyDeleteในวงการคาสิโนออนไลน์นี้คงไม่มีผู้เล่นคนไหน ไม่รู้จัก BETFLIX999.NET เพื่อสร้างความเชื่อใจและไว้ใจในการบริการของ BETFLIK68 ด้วยการจัดโปรโมชั่น ให้ได้ร่วมลุ้นในทุกเดือน
ReplyDeleteเกมส์ สล็อตออนไลน์ pc เกมออนไลน์ต่างๆต่างมู่ไปสู่แพลตฟอร์มของโทรศัพท์มันเป็นอะไรกันไปหมด แม้ว่า PC นั้นสามารถเล่นได้เช่นเดียวกัน พวกเราจะพามาเจอกับเกมส์ PGSLOT ออนไลน์
ReplyDelete